How do you solve a murder when everyone has a motive?

Review: Vivien Horler

Close to Death, by Anthony Horowitz (Century/ Penguin Random House)

In his acknowledgements Anthony Horowitz writes: “This was quite a complicated novel to write….”

I thought it was quite a complicated novel to read – and I’m still not sure who the baddy was.

But I thoroughly enjoyed the process.

Until last month I’m not sure I’d read Horowitz before, or certainly not his Hawthorne novels.

In these murder thrillers Horowitz becomes a fictional alter ego in his own books, working as a writer alongside Daniel Hawthorne, a former top detective who left the police under a cloud (an accused in handcuffs slipped down the stairs, and Hawthorne was right behind him) and is called in as a freelancer to help solve tricky cases.

My first Hawthorne novel – read just last month – was The Sentence is Death, published in 2018, a tale about a divorce lawyer bludgeoned to death in his London home.

Hawthorne is seconded to the case, and Horowitz, who has a three-book contract to write about Hawthorne, stumbles along behind him, trying to figure out what’s going on. Hawthorne doesn’t think much of Horowitz’s detection abilities. It was a great read on a long flight. Continue reading

Don’t let the title put you off – this is an entirely satisfying novella

Review: Archie Henderson

The English Understand Wool, by Helen DeWitt (Storybook ND)

The title was enough to deter me, but the size and the cover did appeal (yes, you can sometimes judge a book by those!) Wool, it turned out, is a warm, comforting read.

DeWitt is best known for her debut novel, The Last Samurai. It was her 50th completed manuscript, which she finally handed in to a publisher in 1998, hitting the shelves in 2000. Then began a runaround for the author after the publisher went belly up, leading to what appears to have been terrible exploitation of DeWitt.

Behind the enervating attempt to be published and what followed must lie a story: a difficult relationship with publishers. Is Wool her revenge? It certainly is not a good optic for publishing and all who sail in it, from agents, to lawyers and all the rest of that crew. Continue reading

If you’re taking only one bird field guide, this is the one

Review: Lyn Mair

Birds of Greater Southern Africa, by Keith Barnes, Terry Stevenson and John Fanshaw; illustrated by John Gale and Brian Small, with Faansie Peacock illustrating the lark complex (Helm Field Guides)

This importan and ambitious new field guide to the birds of greater Southern Africa offers much more than a quick ID with distribution maps.

It covers a huge area from the southern tip of Africa to the entire countries of Zambia, Malawi, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Namibia, Botswana and South Africa with Lesotho and Eswatini.

Also included are the waters of the Mozambique Channel with Europa Island, and the African part of the Southern Ocean with its many islands including Gough, the Tristan da Cunha archipelago, and Marion and Prince Edward islands. Continue reading

Books always add magic

Review: Beryl Eichenberger

The Bookshop Ladies, by Faith Hogan (Head of Zeus)

Anything with “book” in the title is an immediate attraction and so far I have not been disappointed. There is always a magic released when books are involved.

The Bookshop Ladies by Faith Hogan is a delightful book club read. Its easy narrative sweeps you along, the twists surprising, the outcomes fairly predictable but all in all, it held my attention.

It starts in Paris, a retirement party for an acclaimed gallerist and art dealer, a drive home that ends in tragedy and a revelation that sets in motion a ricocheting chain of events event – changing lives, settling scores, but ultimately leaving everyone in their rightful places. And with the background of a bookstore – well, what could go wrong? Continue reading

Bedside Table Books forOctober

These are among the books that have landed on my desk recently. The top four – Breaking Bread by Jonathan Jansen, Revenge of the Tipping Point by Malcolm Gladwell, Catherine, the Princess of Wales by Robert Jobson and Intermezzo, by Sally Rooney – are from Exclusive Books’s top reads for October. Some of these books will be reviewed in full later. – Vivien Horler

Breaking Bread – a memoir, by Jonathan Jansen (Jonathan Ball)

Jonathan Jansen is something of a national treasure. He has opinions on everything, primarily on education in South Africa, but he doesn’t confine himself to that subject. He’s been described as a professor, a pundit and even a public nuisance.

His is a prolific writer, has written many books, occasionally more than one at a time. He also writes columns and is often seen on social media.

After a stint as rector and vice-chancellor of the University of the Free State – he started there in the wake of the dreadful racist urination into food  incident – he became distinguished professor of education at Stellenbosch University, and says now he is relieved of administration duties, he can do what professors are supposed to do: think.

He grew up on the Cape Flats, the eldest son of an intensely religious couple called Abraham and Sarah (and yes, he has a brother called Isaac) who were members of what he calls a fervent community of evangelical Christians. This gave him his founding values, and he says while he eventually he left the church, ”in many ways it never left me”.

He frames his life within the broader community, and says an important goal of this memoir  was to give readers a sense of time and place… ”Put differently, this is not simply the straightforward story of a grateful life but one of a resilient community on the Cape Flats”.

Revenge of the Tipping Point – Overstories, superspreaders, and the rise of social engineering, by Malcolm Gladwell (Abacus Books)

Malcolm Gladwell’s best-selling The Tipping PointHow little things make a big difference was published 25 years ago, and he wrote that it was “the biography of an idea”. It’s about trends, and what makes them spread, or as he puts it, “ideas and products and messages and behaviors spread, just like viruses do”. The book spent several years – years! – on the New York Times bestseller lists.

The idea for this new book was to revisit some of the ideas published a quarter of a century ago, and then he realised he didn’t want to return to ground he had covered earlier as that world just seemed too different from our world today.

So he started again, and this book is the result. It is ”a new set of theories, stories and arguments about the strange pathways that ideas and behavior follow through our world”.

If it is half as interesting as The Tipping Point he’ll have another bestseller on his hands.

Catherine, the Princess of Wales – The biography, by Robert Jobson (John Blake Publishing)

Princess Catherine was of course always going to be a big story – beautiful, smart and the girlfriend of Prince William. But it seems in this past year or so, as she became the Princess of Wales, and took the public into her confidence about her cancer diagnosis, she has become something more – a person that people from all walks of life can identify with, a mum and – well, just nice.

Robert Jobson is a royal correspondent, and Catherine is only the latest in a number of titles he has written about members of the British royal family, including King Charles, Prince Philip, Princess Diana and Prince William, so he would seem well placed to write this biography.

He has attended many royal events in the UK, been on overseas tours as an accredited royal correspondent, and has met the Princess of Wales several times.

His sources for this biography are numerous, including members of the royal household, both on and off the record.

I noted the pictures in this book do not include the famous one of Catherine in a see-through dress modelling at St Andrew’s University, so could it be this biography is a touch sanitised? Then on the other hand, It seems there is not much to sanitise about Catherine. She seems to be brave and strong, a loving mother and a huge support to her husband.

Intermezzo, by Sally Rooney (faber)

An intermezzo is an interlude, according to Wikipedia,  “a brief show (music or dance etc) inserted between the sections of a longer performance”. Intermezzdo is about two Irish brothers, Peter, a smooth, suave Dublin lawyer in his early 30s, and his much younger brother  Ivan, a competitive chess player and a man who is probably “on the spectrum”.

Their father has just died, and the brothers struggle to come to terms with this. Peter is taking medication to help him sleep, and battling to juggle his relationships with two different women, his first love and a young university student.

As for Ivan, who has always been a loner, he meets an older woman who rapidly becomes an important part of his life.

The cover blurb tells us that “for two grieving brothers and the people they love, this is a new interlude – a period of desire, despair and possibility”.

The First Murder on Mars, by Sam Wilson (Orion/ Jonathan Ball)

This sort of book is really not my thing, I thought, when I first opened the parcel. Mars makes me think of Elon Musk and weirdos like that.

But it has shouts on the back cover from both Sarah Lotz and Lauren Beukes, with Lotz describing it as: “A fiercely intelligent, wholly engaging thrill-ride of a novel that sucks you in like a black hole.”

So I read the first 27 pages, and I think I’m hooked.

It seems to be the year 2103, and the colony on Mars has expanded, much like the one at the Cape did in the years after 1652. There is the Company Territory, the Free Settlements, and Outlier Territory.

It’s all pretty dystopian, with groups in the Free Settlements fighting each other, and the Company ruling with a rod of iron. Preferred methods of execution are tossing people out of the airlock.

The guard, Dylan, who works nights, gets paid extra for working during the slip, the 37 minutes tacked on at the end of the day to make Earth standard time work on Mars.

Food is grown in domes, and paper is made from vat-grown cellulose.

In his acknowledgements, Sam Wilson refers to a talk given in Cape Town by Khai Staats, who is an expert on the ways humans might live on other planets.

He said something along the lines of: “When people first arrive on Mars, things will be simple. There will be a small group of scientists, all working towards the same goals. Everyone will know each other, and everyone will trust each other. But slowly, the population will grow. People will be born, and people will arrive from Earth, and eventually things will stop being simple. There will be growing inequality and distrust, there will be politics, there will be crime, and eventually there will be murder.”

Which was the seed that fired Wilson’s imagination.

Beeld 50 – Om ‘n groote storie hard te slaan, compiled by Erika de Beer (Jonathan Ball Publishers)

In June this year came the devastating news: Media24 was planning to close down the print versions of several of its newspapers, including Beeld, Rapport, City Press, Daily Sun and Soccer Laduma, as well as the digital editions of Volksblad and Die Burger Oos-Kaap.

Three would continue to be published digitally only – Rapport, City Press and the Daily Sun, while the print version of Die Burger would continue.

So ironically in 2024, the year the Afrikaans daily Beeld celebrates its 50th anniversary, it looks as though the title is on the chopping block.

The process seems to have stalled while complex negotiations continue with potential buyers and also the Competition Commission, but in July Media24 said it would continue with Section 189 negotiations, basically rentrenchment negotiations. Around 400 jobs could be lost.

So instead of Beeld 50 being a celebration, it may be an epitaph.

Nevertheless, this is a great book, full of pictures, memories, behind-the-scenes newspaper anecdotes and 50 years of SA news stories.

Journalists – not just Media24 journalists – will smile at some of the memories, such as a reporter being told: “ ‘Calf sucks ma-cow dry’ – that’s the headline, write the story to go with it.” Remember phoning in copy on collect calls from a tickeybox – long before cellphones? Typing stories on manual typewriters, with carbon copies (where do you think the email term CC comes from?)

And then 50 years of news stories, from the Fox Street siege of 1975, the murder of Robert and Jeanne Smit in 1977, the Information Scandal, the bombing of Air Force HQ in Church Street in Pretoria in 1983, the dramas of Zola Budd, the ditching of the Helderberg in 1987, the freeing of Nelson Mandela in 1990, the sinking of the Oceanos in 1991, Chris Hani’s murder, the first democratic elections and Mandela’s inauguration in 1994, our winning the Rugby World Cup in 1995, Archbishop Tutu in tears at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1996, the death of Princess Diana in 1997, the collapse of the Twin Towers in 2001, Charlize Theron winning an Oscar in 2004, Marikana in 2012, Oscar Pistorius’s murder of  Reeva Steenkamp in  2013, the death of Mandela the same year, Thuli Madonsela’s report Secure in Comfort which was the beginning of the end for Jacob Zuma’s presidency, Covid in 2020, the death of FW de Klerk in 2021, the Zondo Commission into State Capture… a story of our times.

One Pot – Cookbook for South Africans, by Louisa Holst (Human & Rousseau)

A year or two ago I was sent Louisa Holst’s SA Air Fryer Cookbook, long before I had an air fryer, so didn’t male much of it. Then I got one of those useful devices, and found the book a boon.

I’ve since bought several copies for family and friends who were also venturing into this newish mode of cooking.

Now Holst has produced One Pot, and this time I don’t have to wait to try it out as I have several pots.

In her introduction she says this cookbook is for those busy days when you need an easy supper-time solution, whether there’s electricity or not (mostly there is, these days, mercifully).

All the dishes in the book are cooked on the stove top, as long as you have a gas hob (and since nothing is done in the oven, you’ll save on electricity too).

The ingredients are easily available, and the ingredient lists are shortish and economical. Nothing should take longer than an hour to prepare.

There are days, she says, when you might have time to spend hours creating slow-cooked specialities; the recipes in this book, which she dubs weeknight winners, are for the other days.

Chapters include one-pot wonders, which are warming comfort food; flash-in-the-pan foods like stir-fries, short-cut pasta dishes, a chapter on breadwinners – quick bread-based meals like Portuguese steak rolls or chutney chicken vetkoek; recipes ideal for batch-cooking for the freezer; a bunch of rice dishes like fish curry and rice and fragrant spiced pork and rice; and then a whole chapter on stove-top treats – try apple fritters or steamed chocolate coffee cake.

I think this cookbook will be a winner.

The long shadow cast by war and how three generations of women in a German family try to cope

Review: Vivien Horler

The Silence in Between, by Josie Ferguson (Doubleday)

Imagine: you live in Claremont in Cape Town and one night you allow your eight-year-old daughter to have a sleepover with her cousin in Bellville. The next day you wake up to discover the city has been divided, and you can’t reach her or get her back.

It seems a ridiculous notion, but it happened in Berlin in August 1961, when the Soviets fenced off the sector of the city over which they had control, dividing thousands of families for nearly 30 years.

This is part of the premise of The Silence in Between, a work of page-turning historical fiction based on true events. Continue reading

An honest and satisfying memoir of negotiating life’s hurdles

Exit Wounds – A story of love, loss and occasional wars, by Peter Godwin (Picador Africa)

Peter Godwin has lived away from Rhodesia/Zimbabwe for a long time, well over 20 years, and yet it continues to define him. Or maybe it’s just that our childhoods do that to all of us.

He grew up in the Chimanimani Mountains, where his British-born mother was a doctor and his Polish-born father an engineer. He had an older sister and a younger sister, but the older one, Jain, died in an ambush, along with her fiancé, shortly after the outbreak of the Rhodesian war.

This memoir is dedicated to his sisters: “Georgina, who lived through so much of this with me. And Jain, who didn’t get to.” Continue reading

Bedside Table September

These are among the books that landed on my desk this month. The first four – Exit Wounds, There are Rivers in the Sky, How to Say Babylon, and The Dark Wives, are part of a list of Exclusive Books’s top reads for September. Some will be reviewed in full later. – Vivien Horler

Exit Wounds: A story of love, loss and occasional wars, by Peter Godwin (Picador Africa)

I pounced on this memoir, having thoroughly appreciated Peter Godwin’s earlier two: Mukiwa, a coming-of-age tale about growing up white in Rhodesia during the war for independence, and When a Crocodile Eats the Sun, about the collapse of his family as Zimbabwe itself goes into a death spiral.

His father dies in the second memoir, by which time Godwin is living in the US, having married a Yorkshire woman he met while a student in the UK. They have a son, and there is a line that struck me: their little family speaks with three different accents.

There was another bit that nearly reduced me to tears: Godwin and his sister want their mother, now elderly and poor thanks to crippling inflation, to leave Zimbabwe and go back to England, but she is resisting them. She’s lived there for 40 years or so, working as a doctor, and when her children pile on the pressure, she sends them a Rudyard Kipling poem purportedly in the voice of a Roman centurion ordered home to Rome after decades in Britain:

“Legate, I come to you in tears – My cohort ordered home!/ I’ve served in Britain forty years. What should I do in Rome?/ Here is my heart, my soul, my mind – the only life I know./ I cannot leave it all behind. Command me not to go!”

But she eventually did leave, as we discover in the opening pages of Exit Wounds. She stays in London with her daughter Georgina, while Peter often flies to see her from New York.

But he says sadly: “There is a sad symmetry to our relationship. I spent the first decade of my life trying to summon my mother’s attention, and she has spent the last decade of hers trying to summon mine.”

There are Rivers in the Sky, by Elif Shafak (Viking/Penguin Books)

This novel has an extraordinarily broad sweep, from the ancient city of Nineveh to Victorian London, then on to Turkey in 2014 and finally back to London in 2018.

The cover blurb tells us this is the story of a lost poem: The Epic of Gilgamesh, two great rivers and three remarkable lives, all connected by a single drop of water, one that keeps being recycled from raindrop to earth and thence back to sky… it’s the sort of story that gets me using the word thence.

I suspect this novel may be a touch higher grade, but it gets enthusiastic shouts from the likes of the great British classicist Mary Beard (“A brilliant, unforgettable novel”) and the best-selling writers Philippa Gregory (“The story flows like the rivers from ancient Nineveh to present-day London, with characters of the distant past as bright and vivid as those of today”), William Boyd, Arundhati Roy and Ian McEwan.

How to Say Babylon – A Jamaican memoir, by Safiya Sinclair (4th Estate)

Safiya Sinclair grew up in Jamaica, desperate to be a writer and live her own life, but she and her family were dominated by her father, a member of a militant Rasta sect who rejected Babylon, his term for the corrupting influence of the West.

She made it – she has written three prize-winning books and is currently an associate professor of creative writing at Arizona State University.

How she escaped her repressive background is the subject of what the Spectator calls “this electrifying memoir”, which was also one of the Guardian’s “best memoirs and biographies of 2023”.

Writer Elif Shafak – see above – said of Babylon: “I absolutely adored this book… Heartbreaking and heartwarming.”

The Dark Wives – A Vera thriller, by Ann Cleeves (Macmillan)

I’m an enormous fan of Ann Cleeves’s various series of detective thrillers: the Shetland novels, the Two Rivers novels and of course the Vera Stanhope novels, as personified in the TV series by the brilliant actress Brenda Blethyn. (“What’s that, pet?”)

In The Dark Wives, an early morning dog walker finds a body (early-morning dog walkers have a lot to answer for) on a common near a care home for troubled teens. He turns out to be Josh, a staff member.

Detective Inspector Vera Stanhope is called in, and finds her only clue is the disappearance of Chloe Spence, 14, one of the home’s residents. Then a second body is found near the Three Dark Wives, standing stones in the Northumbrian countryside, and “superstition and folklore begin to collide with fact”.

Ann Cleeves has dedicated this detective thriller “to teens everywhere, and especially to the Dark Wives – uppity young women with minds of their own struggling to find a place in a difficult world”.

The Super Cadres – ANC misrule in the age of deployment, by Pieter du Toit (Jonathan Ball Publishers)

Quoting ANC chairman Gwede Mantashe, former Chief Justice Raymond Zondo said in his report, into the allegations of state capture, that the strategic deployment of comrades was an important part of the ANC’s strategy to control the levers of state power.

And we know where that has led. In the prologue to what is clearly an important book about the state of our nation, Pieter du Toit writes that as the party’s secretary general during its most destructive decade, its chair since 2017 “and one of the most enthusiastic defenders of its “ruinous cadre deployment policy, [Gwede Mantashe] bears more responsibility than most for [the party’s] fate in the 2024 elections.

“Mantashe represents a refusal to reform. And the downfall of the ANC.”

In his introduction, Du Toit writes that cadre deployment was formalised as far back as 1997 as a mechanism to ensure the party’s complete dominance over power in the state.

The system, introduced during Nelson Mandela’s time at the helm of both party and country, “but formulated and implemented by [Thabo] Mbeki, ensured that the ANC’s culture of patronage politics and rent-seeking would flourish. Mbeki’s intention with cadre deployment was to ensure the supremacy of African nationalism and party control. But what it eventually led to was the severe weakening of the state, institutional corruption and the rise of a predatory class of ANC deployees focused on large-scale resource extraction”.

Du Toit says his book exposes the depravity of cadre deployment. He goes further, he says, and attempts to explain how the ANC’s super cadres, a class of political power brokers and party headmen, consolidated their power and how the ANC squandered almost every opportunity to modernise SA after 1994, bringing the country to the brink.

Blood Brothers – to Operation Smokeshell and back, by Leon Lamprecht (Jonathan Ball Publishers)

As a female, I was never conscripted into the SA Defence Force, and when I was of an age to have boyfriends and a brother in the military – all in the navy for one thing, so based at Saldanha, Gordon’s Bay and Simon’s Town – it seemed a more innocent age.

As a result I’ve never been particularly interested in the slew of books that have been written about the ghastly experiences of the troepies (and fighters on the other side) in the then South West Africa and Angola.

Journalist Deon Lamprecht was with 61 Mech in Angola, and has now written three books about the war. This one is about a battle he was not part of, which wreaked terrible damage on both sides.

But he says this book is not about glorifying a long-ago war – the battle of Smokeshell took place on a single day in June 1980 – “it is about camaraderie, mutual respect and social support in the here and now”.

It also talks about the horror that can still surface among the men who fought there, and the physical pain and disability some of them suffer to this day.

Spy novel fails to live up to early promise

Review: Archie Henderson

Beirut Station: Two lives of a spy, by Paul Vidich (Pegasus/No Exit Press)

With the devastation in Gaza and the prospect of another war breaking out in Lebanon (did the last one ever end?), this novel seemed like a good idea – if it could explain some of the complexities of Middle East politics. It fell short.

This is a shame since Paul Vidich’s The Matchmaker about West Berlin shortly before the Wall came down was an entertaining spy novel and praised for its “casual elegance” by the New York Times. Vidich strives for that kind of elegance in Beirut Station, but fails to achieve it.

The first problem is the main character. Analise Assad is a Lebanese-American who speaks fluent Arabic. She should be a convincing CIA operative in a hotbed of international intrigue, but she comes across as someone from whom the agency would run a mile before hiring, let alone parachuting into a war zone. Continue reading

Heart-breaking but hopeful memoir of a life that became voiceless

Review: Beryl Eichenberger

Hot Tea and Apricots, by Kim Ballantine (Self-published)

When I saw the title of this memoir, I was immediately eager to read it. I mean, Hot Tea and Apricots – where would you find a title like that? And within moments the explanation was there as part of the author’s note setting the tone for the book.

Because Kim’s story is unlike any I have read. And the title reveals so much in terms of coping, taking those steps towards conquering the mountains that faced Kim.

Hot tea and apricots is a sherpa’s response to climbing a high peak, a response to that loss of faith when you think you won’t make it, a response of hope and finding the strength to move on. Continue reading